Covers can be a contentious subject. Is a cop out? Should an artist only perform original songs? Are you a lesser artist if you don’t write your own material? Can of worms, right here…A lot of artists or musicians can be quite disparaging of covers. But I think it all comes down to choice, and by that I mean the choice of repertoire.
This is something at the forefront of my mind right now, as I am currently working on my own covers project. It started out as an EP and is turning into an album and I have to say I am really enjoying the process.
I love the covers I have picked, obviously. They mean a lot to me, I never pick repertoire that I don’t connect with. I am hoping they are innovative enough to sound fresh and new, with a respectful nod to the artist or band and time in which they originally sit.
I learned very quickly in my Jazz gig days that the best songs I sang were the ones I connected with. There are so many beautiful songs out there, but if I didn’t relate to them lyrically or melodically, how could I sing them credibly to you, and make you believe me?
And I think that’s the point. Singing covers in my view is just another way of expressing yourself and presenting your creative vision. Covers to me are a bit like a performance of a play, the text can be read in a number of ways and if executed with thought and intention the result can be wonderful, and as valid as the original.
The cover that springs to mind here is Adele’s, “Make you feel my love”. Written and originally recorded by Bob Dylan, Adele has done a beautiful job of this song in my opinion and I feel made Bob Dylan much more accessible to a generation who is unfamiliar with his work, which is a great thing. One of my favourite covers is Tori Amos’ version of the Boomtown Rats’, “I don’t like Mondays”, well worth a listen, if you haven’t heard it.
What is interesting though is I feel there are some songs that can’t be “made your own” to use that dreadful X factor phrase. You can state them, as they are heart-stoppingly beautiful but they can’t be tampered with, or stray too far from the original concept. Joni Mitchell’s “Both sides now” and “17” by Janis Ian come to mind. But hey, if you know a really different version of either of these songs please let me know.
Personally I feel covers have their place; they are a great way of instantly connecting with an audience who doesn’t know you. I love hearing artists I admire sing covers and often get inspired with what they have done. So what do you think – yes or no to covers?